Pitchgrade
Pitchgrade

Presentations made painless

Company > The Rubicon Project: Business Model, SWOT Analysis, and Competitors 2024

The Rubicon Project: Business Model, SWOT Analysis, and Competitors 2024

Published: Feb 19, 2024

Inside This Article

menumenu

    The Rubicon Project, a prominent name in the digital advertising industry, has revolutionized how online ads are bought and sold through its innovative technology platform. This blog article delves into the core aspects of the company's business model, providing a detailed SWOT analysis to uncover its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. Additionally, it offers a comprehensive look at the competitive landscape for 2024, highlighting key players and market dynamics shaping the future of digital advertising.

    ### What You Will Learn

    • Ownership and Mission: Discover who owns The Rubicon Project and understand its core mission statement.
    • Business Model and Revenue: Learn how The Rubicon Project generates revenue and explore an in-depth explanation of its Business Model Canvas.
    • Competitive Landscape and SWOT Analysis: Identify key competitors of The Rubicon Project and gain insights through a comprehensive SWOT analysis.

    Who owns The Rubicon Project?

    Who owns The Rubicon Project?

    The Rubicon Project, now known as Magnite, is a prominent player in the digital advertising technology space. The company underwent a significant rebranding in April 2020 following its merger with Telaria, another leading ad tech firm. This merger was a strategic move aimed at creating the largest independent sell-side advertising platform, combining Rubicon Project's programmatic expertise with Telaria's video capabilities.

    Magnite operates as a publicly traded company and is listed on the NASDAQ stock exchange under the ticker symbol "MGNI." As a publicly traded entity, Magnite is owned by its shareholders, which include a mix of institutional investors, mutual funds, and individual stakeholders. Some of its largest institutional shareholders are investment firms and pension funds, which collectively hold a significant percentage of the company's shares.

    The company's executive team and board of directors also play a crucial role in its ownership structure and governance. Key figures such as the CEO, CFO, and other top executives, along with the board members, are pivotal in steering the strategic direction of the company. They are often compensated with stock options and shares, aligning their interests with those of the shareholders.

    In summary, while no single entity or individual "owns" The Rubicon Project outright, its ownership is distributed among a wide array of public and institutional investors. This diversified ownership helps ensure a broad base of support and accountability, contributing to the company's robust governance and operational strategy.

    What is the mission statement of The Rubicon Project?

    What is the mission statement of The Rubicon Project?

    The Rubicon Project, now part of Magnite, was founded with a clear and ambitious mission: "to automate the buying and selling of advertising." This mission encapsulates the company's core objective of streamlining the often complex and fragmented digital advertising ecosystem. By leveraging advanced technology and data-driven insights, The Rubicon Project aims to create a more efficient, transparent, and effective marketplace for both publishers and advertisers.

    At its heart, the mission is about simplifying the ad transaction process, reducing inefficiencies, and maximizing the value of digital ad inventory. The Rubicon Project seeks to empower publishers to better monetize their content while providing advertisers with the tools and access they need to reach their target audiences at scale.

    In pursuit of this mission, The Rubicon Project has developed a suite of innovative solutions, including real-time bidding (RTB), programmatic advertising, and header bidding. These technologies are designed to optimize ad placements, improve yield, and enhance the overall user experience.

    Moreover, the mission extends beyond mere automation; it is also about fostering trust and collaboration within the digital advertising industry. The Rubicon Project is committed to maintaining high standards of integrity, transparency, and accountability, ensuring that all stakeholders—publishers, advertisers, and consumers—benefit from a fair and open marketplace.

    In summary, the mission statement of The Rubicon Project reflects a dedication to transforming digital advertising through automation and innovation, while upholding the principles of transparency and trust. This mission continues to drive the company's efforts to redefine the future of advertising in an increasingly digital world.

    How does The Rubicon Project make money?

    How does The Rubicon Project make money?

    The Rubicon Project, now known as Magnite after its merger with Telaria, operates as a leading independent sell-side advertising platform. The company generates revenue primarily through the following streams:

    1. Transaction Fees

    The core of The Rubicon Project's business model revolves around transaction fees. When publishers use their platform to sell ad inventory, The Rubicon Project charges a fee for facilitating these transactions. This fee is typically a percentage of the total transaction value. By providing a marketplace where buyers and sellers can connect efficiently, the company earns a steady stream of income.

    2. Subscription Fees

    In addition to transaction fees, The Rubicon Project offers premium services and tools to publishers on a subscription basis. These tools may include advanced analytics, audience insights, and enhanced ad-serving capabilities. Publishers pay a recurring fee to access these value-added services, providing another revenue stream for the company.

    3. Data and Analytics Services

    Data is a critical asset in the digital advertising ecosystem. The Rubicon Project leverages its vast amount of data to offer analytics services to both publishers and advertisers. By providing insights into audience behavior, ad performance, and market trends, the company helps clients optimize their advertising strategies. This data-driven approach not only enhances the effectiveness of ads but also commands a premium price for these analytics services.

    4. Managed Services

    For clients who prefer a more hands-off approach, The Rubicon Project offers managed services. In this model, the company takes over the entire ad operations process, from strategy and planning to execution and optimization. Clients pay for the convenience and expertise, allowing The Rubicon Project to capture additional revenue through service fees.

    5. Partnerships and Integrations

    The Rubicon Project has established numerous partnerships and integrations with other technology providers in the ad tech ecosystem. These collaborations often include revenue-sharing agreements, where The Rubicon Project earns a portion of the revenue generated through these joint efforts. By expanding its network and enhancing its platform's capabilities through partnerships, the company can attract more clients and increase its revenue potential.

    Conclusion

    The Rubicon Project, through a combination of transaction fees, subscription services, data analytics, managed services, and strategic partnerships, has built a robust and diversified revenue model. This multi-faceted approach not only drives consistent income but also positions the company as a crucial player in the digital advertising landscape.

    The Rubicon Project Business Model Canvas Explained

    Key Partners

    The Rubicon Project, now known as Magnite, collaborates with a variety of strategic partners to enhance its service offerings and expand its market reach. These partners include:

    • Advertisers and Agencies: Major brands and advertising agencies that utilize Rubicon's platform to reach their target audiences.
    • Publishers: Content creators and media companies that provide the ad inventory.
    • Technology Partners: Companies that provide the necessary technological infrastructure, such as data analytics, cloud services, and cybersecurity.
    • Third-Party Data Providers: Organizations that offer valuable audience data to improve ad targeting and effectiveness.

    Key Activities

    Rubicon Project's core activities revolve around managing and optimizing its advertising exchange platform. Key activities include:

    • Platform Development and Maintenance: Continuous improvement of the ad exchange platform to ensure it remains robust, scalable, and user-friendly.
    • Data Analysis: Leveraging big data to provide actionable insights and improve ad targeting.
    • Customer Support: Offering dedicated support to publishers and advertisers to help them maximize their use of the platform.
    • Marketing and Sales: Promoting the platform to attract new publishers and advertisers and drive revenue growth.

    Key Resources

    The company's success hinges on several critical resources:

    • Technology Infrastructure: High-performance servers, cloud computing resources, and advanced software systems.
    • Human Capital: Skilled employees, including engineers, data scientists, sales professionals, and customer support staff.
    • Data Assets: Proprietary and third-party data that enhance ad targeting and performance.
    • Intellectual Property: Patents, trademarks, and proprietary technologies that provide a competitive edge.

    Value Propositions

    Rubicon Project offers significant value to both advertisers and publishers:

    • For Advertisers: Access to a vast inventory of premium ad space, advanced targeting capabilities, and real-time bidding to optimize ad spend and improve ROI.
    • For Publishers: Monetization of digital content through efficient and effective ad placements, access to a large pool of advertisers, and tools to maximize yield and fill rates.

    Customer Relationships

    The company maintains strong relationships with its customers through:

    • Account Management: Dedicated account managers who provide personalized service and support.
    • Customer Support: 24/7 customer service to address any issues or questions.
    • Community Engagement: Hosting events, webinars, and forums to engage with and educate the customer base.

    Channels

    Rubicon Project reaches its customers through several channels:

    • Direct Sales: A dedicated sales team that engages directly with large advertisers and publishers.
    • Online Platform: A user-friendly online portal where customers can manage their ad campaigns and inventory.
    • Partnerships: Collaborations with other ad tech companies and media agencies to expand market reach.

    Customer Segments

    The company serves multiple customer segments:

    • Large Advertisers: Big brands looking for extensive reach and advanced targeting.
    • Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs): Smaller businesses that need cost-effective advertising solutions.
    • Publishers: Media companies and content creators seeking to monetize their digital content.
    • Ad Agencies: Intermediaries that manage advertising campaigns for various clients.

    Cost Structure

    Rubicon Project's cost structure includes:

    • Technology Costs: Investments in servers, software development, and cloud services.
    • Employee Salaries: Compensation for engineers, sales staff, customer support, and other key personnel.
    • Marketing Expenses: Costs associated with promoting the platform and acquiring new customers.
    • Operational Costs: Day-to-day expenses including office space, utilities, and administrative costs.

    Revenue Streams

    The company generates revenue through:

    • Transaction Fees: Charging fees for each ad transaction processed through its platform.
    • Subscription Fees: Offering premium services and features on a subscription basis.
    • Data Monetization: Selling anonymized audience data to advertisers for better targeting.
    • Service Fees: Additional fees for custom solutions, consulting, and managed services.

    By understanding Rubicon Project's business model canvas, one can see how the company effectively bridges the gap between advertisers and publishers, creating value for both sides through a well-integrated ad exchange platform.

    Which companies are the competitors of The Rubicon Project?

    Which companies are the competitors of The Rubicon Project?

    The Rubicon Project, now known as Magnite following its merger with Telaria, operates in the robust and highly competitive digital advertising technology industry. Several companies vie for market share in this space, each offering unique solutions and platforms to advertisers, publishers, and marketers. Here are some of the primary competitors of Magnite (formerly The Rubicon Project):

    1. Google Ad Manager

    Google Ad Manager is one of the most prominent players in the ad tech industry. As a comprehensive ad management platform, it combines the features of DoubleClick for Publishers (DFP) and Google Ad Exchange (AdX). Its extensive reach and integration with the Google ecosystem make it a formidable competitor. Google Ad Manager helps publishers manage their ad inventory and optimize revenue through advanced targeting and real-time bidding.

    2. The Trade Desk

    The Trade Desk is a leading demand-side platform (DSP) that enables advertisers to create, manage, and optimize digital advertising campaigns across various channels, including display, video, audio, and connected TV. Known for its powerful data management capabilities and user-friendly interface, The Trade Desk provides robust tools for audience targeting and performance measurement, making it a key competitor in the programmatic advertising landscape.

    3. AppNexus (Xandr)

    AppNexus, which was acquired by AT&T and rebranded as Xandr, is another significant competitor in the ad tech arena. Xandr offers a suite of solutions for both the buy and sell sides of the digital advertising ecosystem. Its technology supports programmatic buying and selling, and it provides advanced analytics and audience insights. Xandr's integration with AT&T's vast media assets enhances its competitive edge.

    4. PubMatic

    PubMatic is a global ad tech company that provides a comprehensive sell-side platform (SSP) for publishers. It offers solutions for header bidding, real-time bidding, and private marketplaces, enabling publishers to maximize ad revenue. PubMatic's focus on transparency, efficiency, and innovation makes it a strong competitor, particularly in the programmatic advertising space.

    5. OpenX

    OpenX is another major player in the ad tech industry, offering both SSP and ad exchange solutions. OpenX focuses on delivering high-quality advertising experiences through its robust technology and data-driven approach. It partners with premium publishers and advertisers to facilitate efficient and effective ad transactions. OpenX's emphasis on transparency and quality control helps it stand out in a crowded market.

    6. Verizon Media (formerly Oath)

    Verizon Media, previously known as Oath, encompasses a wide range of digital media and advertising technologies. As part of Verizon Communications, it leverages extensive data and media assets to provide advertisers and publishers with advanced targeting and monetization solutions. Verizon Media's comprehensive ad tech stack competes directly with Magnite's offerings in programmatic advertising and beyond.

    7. Criteo

    Criteo is a global technology company specializing in performance marketing and retargeting solutions. It helps advertisers deliver personalized ads to users who have previously interacted with their brand, driving higher engagement and conversions. Criteo's focus on data-driven advertising and its extensive network of partners make it a key competitor in the digital ad space.

    These companies, along with many others, create a dynamic and competitive environment for Magnite. Each brings unique strengths and innovations to the table, pushing the boundaries of what is possible in the digital advertising industry. As the landscape continues to evolve, competition among these entities will drive further advancements and improvements in ad tech solutions.

    The Rubicon Project SWOT Analysis

    The Rubicon Project SWOT Analysis

    The Rubicon Project, a major player in the digital advertising space, has experienced various successes and challenges over the years. Conducting a SWOT analysis provides valuable insights into the company's strategic position by examining its Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats.

    Strengths

    1. Advanced Technology Platform: The Rubicon Project boasts a sophisticated and scalable technology platform that facilitates real-time bidding and programmatic advertising. This technological edge allows for efficient and effective ad placements, enhancing the value proposition for both advertisers and publishers.

    2. Strong Market Presence: With a well-established brand and substantial market share, Rubicon has built strong relationships with key stakeholders in the industry. Their extensive network of premium publishers and advertisers enhances their market credibility and reach.

    3. Data-Driven Insights: Leveraging vast amounts of data, Rubicon provides valuable insights and analytics to its clients, enabling them to make informed decisions and optimize their advertising strategies. This data-centric approach is crucial in the digital advertising landscape.

    4. Global Reach: The Rubicon Project operates on a global scale, with a presence in multiple countries. This international footprint allows them to tap into diverse markets and offer localized solutions to their clients.

    Weaknesses

    1. High Dependence on Programmatic Advertising: While programmatic advertising is a key strength, it also represents a potential vulnerability. The heavy reliance on this single revenue stream could pose risks if market dynamics shift or if there are significant changes in industry regulations.

    2. Competitive Market: The digital advertising sector is highly competitive, with numerous players vying for market share. Rubicon faces intense competition from other established firms as well as emerging startups, which could impact their growth and profitability.

    3. Operational Costs: Maintaining and upgrading a sophisticated technology platform requires significant investment. High operational costs can impact profitability, especially during periods of economic downturn or reduced advertising budgets.

    Opportunities

    1. Growth in Digital Advertising: The digital advertising market continues to expand, driven by increasing internet penetration and the shift towards online consumption. Rubicon is well-positioned to capitalize on this growth by offering innovative solutions and expanding its client base.

    2. Emerging Technologies: Advancements in artificial intelligence, machine learning, and big data analytics present new opportunities for Rubicon. By integrating these technologies into their platform, they can enhance ad targeting, personalization, and overall campaign effectiveness.

    3. Expanding Partnerships: Strengthening and expanding partnerships with key industry players, such as media companies and technology providers, can open up new revenue streams and enhance Rubicon's market position. Collaborative ventures and strategic alliances can drive innovation and growth.

    4. Regulatory Changes: While regulatory changes can pose threats, they also present opportunities. Companies that proactively adapt to new regulations and prioritize transparency and data privacy can build trust with clients and gain a competitive edge in the market.

    Threats

    1. Regulatory and Compliance Risks: The digital advertising industry is subject to various regulations related to data privacy and consumer protection. Non-compliance with these regulations can result in legal penalties and damage to reputation, posing a significant threat to Rubicon's operations.

    2. Market Saturation: As the market becomes increasingly saturated, maintaining growth and profitability becomes more challenging. Rubicon must continuously innovate and differentiate itself to stay ahead of competitors and capture market share.

    3. Economic Uncertainty: Economic downturns and fluctuations in advertising budgets can impact Rubicon's revenue streams. During periods of economic uncertainty, advertisers may reduce their spending, affecting the demand for digital advertising services.

    4. Technological Disruptions: Rapid technological advancements and shifts in consumer behavior can disrupt the digital advertising landscape. Rubicon needs to stay ahead of these changes and adapt its strategies to remain relevant and competitive.

    Conducting a SWOT analysis helps Rubicon Project identify areas of strength to leverage, weaknesses to address, opportunities to pursue, and threats to mitigate. By continuously assessing these factors, the company can develop strategic initiatives that drive growth and long-term success in the dynamic digital advertising industry.

    ### Key Takeaways

    • Ownership: The Rubicon Project, now known as Magnite, is a publicly traded company, meaning it is owned by shareholders who purchase its stock on the open market.
    • Mission Statement: The mission of The Rubicon Project is to empower the world's leading agencies, publishers, and brands to optimize advertising revenue and reach their audiences effectively.
    • Revenue Generation: The Rubicon Project makes money primarily through its automated advertising exchange, which charges fees for facilitating digital ad transactions between buyers and sellers.
    • Business Model Canvas: The Rubicon Project's business model revolves around key elements such as its value proposition of providing a transparent and efficient ad marketplace, customer segments including publishers and advertisers, and revenue streams from transaction fees.
    • Competition and SWOT Analysis: Key competitors include companies like Google Ad Manager, AppNexus, and PubMatic. The SWOT analysis reveals strengths such as a strong technological platform, weaknesses like market dependency, opportunities in the growing digital ad market, and threats from intense competition and regulatory changes.

    Conclusion

    In conclusion, The Rubicon Project, now known as Magnite, has established itself as a pivotal player in the digital advertising ecosystem. Owned by Magnite, Inc., the company's mission statement emphasizes its commitment to enabling a vibrant and transparent marketplace for digital advertising. This mission is achieved through its advanced technology platform that automates the buying and selling of digital advertising, ensuring efficiency and transparency for all stakeholders involved.

    The Rubicon Project generates revenue primarily through transaction fees on its platform, where it connects advertisers and publishers. By facilitating these transactions, the company capitalizes on the growing demand for programmatic advertising solutions.

    The Rubicon Project's business model canvas reveals a comprehensive strategy that integrates key activities, resources, and partnerships aimed at delivering value to its clients. Its focus on innovation, customer relationships, and a robust technological infrastructure underscores its competitive advantage in the market.

    However, The Rubicon Project faces stiff competition from other major players in the digital advertising space, including Google Ad Manager, The Trade Desk, and MediaMath. These companies offer similar programmatic solutions and continuously innovate to capture a larger market share.

    A SWOT analysis of The Rubicon Project highlights its strengths in technological innovation and market presence, but also points out challenges such as intense competition and the need for constant adaptation to evolving industry standards and regulations.

    In navigating these challenges and leveraging its strengths, The Rubicon Project continues to be a formidable force in the digital advertising industry, driving forward with a clear mission and a strategic business model designed for sustained growth and success.

    FAQs

    What is the SWOT analysis of a project?

    SWOT analysis is a strategic planning tool used to evaluate the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats related to a project. It helps in understanding both the internal and external factors that can impact the project's success. Here's a breakdown of each component:

    1. Strengths:

      • Internal attributes that give the project an advantage over others.
      • Examples:
        • Strong project team with relevant expertise.
        • Adequate funding and resources.
        • Support from stakeholders or management.
        • Unique or superior technology or methodology.
    2. Weaknesses:

      • Internal attributes that place the project at a disadvantage relative to others.
      • Examples:
        • Lack of experience or skills in the project team.
        • Insufficient resources or funding.
        • Poor project planning or unclear objectives.
        • Weak stakeholder support or engagement.
    3. Opportunities:

      • External factors that the project could exploit to its advantage.
      • Examples:
        • Emerging market trends or demands.
        • Technological advancements.
        • Potential partnerships or collaborations.
        • Changes in regulations that could benefit the project.
    4. Threats:

      • External factors that could cause trouble for the project.
      • Examples:
        • Economic downturns or market volatility.
        • New competitors entering the market.
        • Changes in regulations that could hinder the project.
        • Technological changes that could render the project obsolete.

    Steps to Conduct a SWOT Analysis:

    1. Identify the Objective: Clearly define the project's goals and objectives.
    2. Gather Data: Collect relevant information from various sources like team members, stakeholders, market research, etc.
    3. Brainstorm: Hold brainstorming sessions to identify strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats.
    4. Categorize: Organize the identified factors into the SWOT matrix.
    5. Analyze: Evaluate the impact of each factor and prioritize them based on their significance.
    6. Develop Strategies: Formulate strategies to leverage strengths, mitigate weaknesses, capitalize on opportunities, and counteract threats.

    Example:

    Project: Development of a New Mobile App

    • Strengths:

      • Experienced development team.
      • Strong financial backing.
      • Innovative features not available in competing apps.
    • Weaknesses:

      • Tight project timeline.
      • Limited marketing expertise.
      • Dependence on third-party APIs.
    • Opportunities:

      • Growing demand for mobile apps in the target market.
      • Potential for partnerships with popular tech influencers.
      • Advances in mobile technology enabling new features.
    • Threats:

      • Rapidly changing technology landscape.
      • High competition from established apps.
      • Regulatory changes affecting data privacy.

    By conducting a SWOT analysis, project managers and teams can gain a comprehensive understanding of the project's current standing and develop strategies to enhance its chances of success.

    What are the 5 elements of SWOT analysis?

    SWOT analysis is a strategic planning tool used to identify and analyze the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats related to a business or project. The five elements of SWOT analysis are:

    1. Strengths: These are the internal attributes and resources that support a successful outcome. Strengths could include a strong brand reputation, a loyal customer base, unique technology, or skilled employees.

    2. Weaknesses: These are the internal factors that might hinder the achievement of objectives. Weaknesses could be outdated technology, lack of capital, poor location, or inadequate supply chain management.

    3. Opportunities: These are external factors that the organization could exploit to its advantage. Opportunities might include market growth, emerging trends, favorable regulations, or technological advancements.

    4. Threats: These are external challenges that could cause trouble for the business or project. Threats might include economic downturns, increased competition, changing consumer behavior, or regulatory changes.

    5. Trends: Though not traditionally part of the original SWOT framework, some modern interpretations include trends as a fifth element to account for ongoing changes in the market and industry environment. Trends could impact strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats and provide additional context for strategic planning.

    While SWOT is primarily focused on the first four elements, incorporating trends can offer a more dynamic and forward-looking analysis.

    What are the 4 pillars of SWOT analysis?

    SWOT analysis is a strategic planning tool used to identify and analyze the internal and external factors that can impact an organization's objectives. The four pillars of SWOT analysis are:

    1. Strengths: These are the internal attributes and resources that support a positive outcome. Strengths are what the organization does well or possesses that can give it an advantage over competitors. Examples include strong brand reputation, loyal customer base, efficient processes, proprietary technology, and skilled workforce.

    2. Weaknesses: These are the internal factors that could hinder an organization's ability to achieve its objectives. Weaknesses are areas where the organization is at a disadvantage compared to competitors, or internal limitations that need to be addressed. Examples include limited resources, lack of expertise, poor location, and outdated technology.

    3. Opportunities: These are external factors that the organization can capitalize on or exploit to its advantage. Opportunities are conditions in the external environment that can be favorable for the organization if leveraged properly. Examples include market growth, emerging trends, regulatory changes, and gaps in the market.

    4. Threats: These are external factors that could cause trouble for the organization or put its goals at risk. Threats are conditions in the external environment that could negatively impact the organization if not managed properly. Examples include increasing competition, economic downturns, changing consumer preferences, and new regulations.

    By analyzing these four pillars, organizations can develop strategic plans that leverage their strengths, mitigate their weaknesses, capitalize on opportunities, and protect against threats.

    What are 5 examples of weaknesses in SWOT analysis?

    Certainly! In a SWOT analysis, weaknesses refer to internal factors that may hinder an organization's ability to achieve its objectives. Here are five examples of weaknesses:

    1. Poor Financial Health:

      • High levels of debt or insufficient cash flow can limit the organization's ability to invest in growth opportunities or weather economic downturns.
    2. Lack of Skilled Workforce:

      • A shortage of skilled employees or high employee turnover can reduce productivity and negatively impact the quality of products or services.
    3. Outdated Technology:

      • Relying on obsolete or inefficient technology can make operations less efficient and hinder the company's ability to compete effectively.
    4. Weak Brand Recognition:

      • Limited brand awareness or a negative brand image can reduce customer trust and loyalty, making it harder to attract and retain customers.
    5. Inefficient Processes:

      • Poorly defined or inefficient processes and workflows can lead to increased costs, delays, and reduced overall operational efficiency.

    Identifying these weaknesses in a SWOT analysis can help an organization develop strategies to address and mitigate them.

    Want to research companies faster?

    • instantly

      Instantly access industry insights

      Let PitchGrade do this for me

    • smile

      Leverage powerful AI research capabilities

      We will create your text and designs for you. Sit back and relax while we do the work.

    Explore More Content

    Companies

    Help us improve PitchGrade

    What problem are you trying to solve?